New York City’s Oldest Spanish-Speaking Catholic Church at Risk of Demolition
NEW YORK, NY – In a city known for its melting pot of cultures, the story of New York’s Hispanic and Latino residents is often overlooked. However, one historical landmark is trying to change that narrative. Our Lady of Guadalupe, the city’s oldest Spanish-speaking Catholic congregation, is fighting to preserve its original building amidst fears of possible alteration or destruction.
Our Lady of Guadalupe is a symbol of faith and identity for many Spanish speakers in New York. It holds sentimental value for the community, as it represents a testament to their history. The church, founded 121 years ago, was originally composed of Spaniards, Puerto Ricans, and other Spanish speakers. As the Mexican population in New York grew, they were naturally drawn to the church due to its name.
This vibrant congregation eventually merged with St. Bernard, a larger church, to accommodate the increasing Mexican population. The fusion of cultures led to a thriving community known as “Little Spain.” Our Lady of Guadalupe and the Spanish Benevolent Society became focal points of this community.
However, the future of the church’s original building, located on 14th Street, is now uncertain. The distinct Spanish Baroque facade that has stood for over a century is under threat of alteration or demolition. Advocates and community members are pressing the city to grant landmark status to the building, in recognition of its historical significance.
Unfortunately, the Landmarks Preservation Committee claims that the church’s architecture is not significant enough to warrant such a status. However, many argue that the church’s significance extends far beyond its physical appearance. It represents the journey of Hispanic and Latino residents in New York, their struggles, and their unwavering faith.
Mexican Americans and Latinos celebrate the feast day of Our Lady of Guadalupe on December 12th. The patron saint of Mexico and the Americas, her image is said to have miraculously appeared on a cloak almost 500 years ago near Mexico City. This annual celebration holds even greater sentimental value for the congregation, and losing their original building would be a blow to their community and heritage.
The fight to preserve Our Lady of Guadalupe’s original building is far from over. Advocates remain committed to showcasing its historical significance, not only to the Hispanic community but to the city as a whole. As New York continues to evolve and embrace diversity, it is essential that these symbols of cultural heritage are protected and celebrated.
