New York Prosecutors Drop Charges Against Collectibles Experts in Eagles Lyrics Case
New York prosecutors have dropped a case against three collectibles experts who were accused of illegally possessing and selling hand-drafted lyrics to Eagles hits, including the iconic “Hotel California.” The charges were dismissed after prosecutors disclosed 6,000 pages of communications involving Eagles co-founder Don Henley and his lawyers at the last minute.
The experts – Glenn Horowitz, Craig Inciardi, and Edward Kosinski – were cleared of conspiracy charges related to the disputed ownership of the legal-pad pages used in creating the album “Hotel California,” which remains the third best-selling album in the U.S. The defendants maintained that they were the rightful owners of the lyrics pages, while prosecutors argued that the chain of possession was questionable.
Henley, who felt “victimized” by the outcome, has expressed his intention to pursue the matter in civil courts. Throughout the case, he provided valuable insights into the Eagles’ career and personal struggles, testifying about the band’s history and his own challenges.
The case also raised concerns about attorney-client privilege and the handling of evidence by both prosecutors and the defense. It shed light on the complexities of intellectual property rights in the music industry and the importance of safeguarding creative works.
Although the criminal charges have been dropped, the legal battle over the ownership of the lyrics pages continues in the civil courts. The case serves as a reminder of the murky legal waters that surround valuable music memorabilia and the importance of thorough documentation in proving ownership.
“Zombie enthusiast. Subtly charming travel practitioner. Webaholic. Internet expert.”